BOSTON – The Division of Open Government within the Massachusetts Attorney General’s office issued a finding on Sept. 30 that the Board of Elementary and Secondary Education (BESE) violated the state’s Open Meeting Laws during its meeting on Tuesday, Jan. 23.
The BESE oversees the Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (DESE), the state agency responsible for all public schools services in Massachusetts.
As This Week in Worcester previously reported, the BESE meeting on Jan. 23 featured seven consecutive speakers on antisemitism in Massachusetts public schools to begin the public comment portion of the meeting. Many of the speakers made political statements related to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, the death of civilians in an attack on Oct. 7, 2023 in Israel, and the subsequent war in the Gaza Strip.
The BESE rules give priority to speakers who request in writing to speak prior to the meeting. Its rules also give priority to those speaking to an item on the BESE agenda. No topics related to antisemitism appeared on the agenda for the meeting.
The Massachusetts Open Meeting Law requires public boards, like BESE, to comply with its rules. A guide produced by the office of Attorney General Andrea Joy Campbell, “Open Meeting Law and Education Materials,” says the following related to agenda requirements to comply with the law.
“Meeting notices must be posted in a legible, easily understandable format; contain the date, time, and place of the meeting, including instructions for accessing the meeting if public access is by remote means; and list all topics that the chair reasonably anticipates.”
Defining Antisemitism
After the public speaking portion of the meeting, BESE Chairperson Katherine Craven called a panel of individuals to discuss antisemitism, despite the topic not being announced on its agenda.
Many of the public speakers, and those taking part in the panel, strongly advocated for BESE to adopt the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) working definition of anti-Semitism.
Many government bodies, institutions, and organizations across the world have adopted the IHRA definition of anti-Semitism, including the United States State Department. The definition also faces significant criticism from academia and several organizations, including Israel’s largest human rights organization, B’Tselem, for conflating political criticism of Israel with antisemitism.
Kenneth Stern, the director of Bard’s Center for the Study of Hate at Bard College, was the American Jewish Committee’s anti-Semitism expert and lead drafter of the IHRA working definition. Stern wrote in 2019 that the definition “was never intended to be a campus hate speech code,” and “is an attack on academic freedom and free speech.”
As the topic never appeared on the meeting agenda, providing no notice to the public that the meeting would host the conversation, no alternative viewpoint was presented.
Division of Open Government Finding
Matthew Lindberg, an Assistant Attorney General with the Division of Open Government, authoried the decision in response to complaints from two individuals who filed complaints alleging Open Meeting Law violations. The decision says that, “Following our review, we find that the Board violated the Open Meeting Law as alleged in the complaints.”
Lindberg said that the decision considered the complaints filed, the BESE response, video of the meeting, and the minutes of the meeting to make its finding.
The decision says that during the BESE meeting on Nov. 21, 2023, two students spoke during the public comment portion of the meeting about antisemitism in Massachusetts schools. Lindberg writes that following that meeting, “interest in the subject reached a ‘fever pitch,’ according to Board Chair Katherine Craven.” Other board members also received inquiries about speaking to the BESE on the topic.
The next BESE meeting was Jan. 23.
The report says that Craven exercised “her discretion to extend the public comment period when she invited five individuals to speak on issues relating to antisemitism in schools.” She exchanged time devoted to the chair’s report to extend the public comment period.
Lindberg wrote Craven spoke to those five individuals by phone on Jan. 21 and informed them they could speak during the meeting. During those conversations, Craven did not discuss the substance of the presentations with the speakers, according to the report.
After forty minutes of public comments to start the Jan. 23 meeting, the report quotes Craven as saying, “I’ve invited five members of different groups who I’ve been talking to since October 7 to come up and specifically talk to us about some of the things that are going on out there.” She introduced the first panel member, “to talk about what the IHRA definition is of antisemitism.”
Lindberg concludes that Craven, “knew that at least some, if not all, of these speakers would attend and speak during the January 23 meeting as of January 18, more than 48 hours prior to the meeting,” and that they would speak about antisemitism. “Because the topics addressed by the Panel, antisemitism and antisemitic bullying, were anticipated by Chair Craven more than 48 hours prior to the meeting, they were required to be listed in the notice.”
The report also addresses an assertion in its response to the complaint that, “the topics of antisemitism and antisemitic bullying arose during public comment and were not among the Board’s own topics of discussion.” Lindberg noted that “A public body may not shield a topic from inclusion on the notice by incorporating it into a public comment period.”
Lindberg added:
“We acknowledge the Board’s confusion or uncertainty as to whether the speakers and subject matter of the Panel needed to be separately included on the meting notice. However, based on the totality of the information and circumstances, we find that the Panel’s speakers did not address the Board merely as participants in public comment independent of the Board’s agenda, but rather as a coordinated group who spoke to a topic that was anticipated and deliberately introduced by the Chair, suggesting an imprimatur not typically accorded public comment participants. Therefore, the Board violated the Open Meeting Law by failing to include an anticipated topic on the notice for its January 23 meeting.”
The conclusion of the report orders immediate and future compliance with the Open Meeting Law and “that similar future violations may be considered evidence of intent to violate the law.”
The complainants also requested that the BESE invite a second panel to respond to the proposals of the panel on Jan. 23. Lindberg wrote that, “We decline to order that the Board invite a second panel to respond to the proposals of the January 23 panel, as requested by the complainants.”














