Presented with a resolution to specifically acknowledge LGBTQIA+ students in Worcester and the “right of every child, regardless of gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation, to access a free public K-12 education and the District,” the Worcester School Committee amended the statement to include a long list of traits.Â
School Committee Member Sue Mailman introduced the resolution. Member Molly McCullough introduced the amended version.
As School Committee Member Vaness Alvarez mentioned during comments on the amendment, and others have written and said, the resolution became an “All Lives Matter” statement. That’s true, but doesn’t capture the cowardly political pandering so implicitly on display.
Changing the Conversation
If you don’t understand why many individuals find “All Lives Matter” offensive, it’s quite simple. On its own, it’s not. The context in which it’s used intends to obfuscate the point.
There are very few people who don’t believe that all lives matter. When you respond to the phrase “Black Lives Matter” with “All Lives Matter,” you are diluting the point and changing the conversation. The conversation over the last few years, regardless of how you feel about it, is about the specific threat to Black people by state violence. Avoiding, diluting, or manipulating that conversation means not addressing the issue.
The phrase diminishes the conversation by burying it in the entire population, while refusing to acknowledge the issue raised. The indifference and avoidance is what some find offensive, and is ultimately harmful.
Should we remember all victims of terrorism globally on the anniversary of 9/11? All lives matter. Should ceremonies honoring those members of the military who gave their lives in Iraq or Afghanistan include acknowledgement of Iraqi and Afghan lives lost? All lives matter.
Should the Saint Patrick’s Day Parade in Worcester not include images connected to Irish culture? All heritages matter.
Of course not. That’s stupid.
The Worcester School Committee did exactly that on Thursday.
Federal Cancel Culture of Transgender People
LGBTQIA+ communities often show a great deal of solidarity. When a segment of that population comes under attack, they come together. They have done exactly that in Worcester and elsewhere across the country, after the President of the United States issued an executive order that essentially says that transgender individuals do not exist. He cancelled them.
When people seek to observe their first amendment right “to petition the Government for a redress of grievances,” and the federal government is unresponsive, or the source of said grievance, it is natural that those individuals would look toward their local government.
Worcester residents brought a petition asking the city council to pass a resolution calling for a ceasefire in Gaza. Those petitioners say they gathered 1.500 signatures from residents in the city to support the resolution. That included several residents who have lost family members in the current war in Gaza. Obviously, the federal government has proven unresponsive to their grievances.
Worcester residents from the city’s queer community brought a petition before the Worcester City Council, which seeks the councilors to declare Worcester a sanctuary city for trans people. Councilor Donna Colorio, with support from Councilor Moe Bergman, held the item seeking clarification if the words “sanctuary city” has legal weight (it doesn’t).
A resolution has no legal weight. It is a statement. In both cases, people credibly feel the federal government has abandoned them. They asked for their local government to do nothing more than say something about the specific issues they face.
In Worcester’s city government, that’s just too much to ask.
The city council accumulates plenty of experience passing items with no legal weight every time it meets. Everything it does that isn’t hiring or firing the city manager, passing an ordinance, or approving the annual budget is an exercise in having no power. That’s the only three things the city charter empowers it to do.
The “But Everyone” Resolution
What started as a “LGBTQ+ Safe Schools Resolution” became a “Safe Schools Resolution” by the time the school committee turned it into government speak, rather than a statement that addressed the moment.
In the original resolution submitted by Mailman, the first two statements said:
“WHEREAS, it is the right of every child, regardless of gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation, to access a free public K-12 education and the District welcomes and supports
all students;
WHEREAS, the District has a responsibility to ensure that all students who reside within its boundaries ,regardless of gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation can safely access a free public K-12 education;”
By the time the school committee turned it into the “Safe Schools Resolution,” the first two statements said:
“WHEREAS, every child has the right to a free public K-12 education, free from discrimination, bullying, and harassment, regardless of race, color, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, religion, disability, age, or any other category protected by state or federal law;
WHEREAS, the District is committed to continuing to foster a safe, inclusive, and supportive learning environment for all students and staff;”
Well, isn’t that inclusive of a bunch of people not declared cancelled by the federal government?
You can see Mailman’s version and McCullough’s version.
Only members Mailman, Alvarez, and Jermaine Johnson voted for Mailman’s version.
That Members Diana Biancheria and Maureen Binienda voted to ignore the moment is unsurprising. Their inclusivity credentials include at least one of them complaining during nearly every school committee meeting that more kids need to be expelled. Inclusivity is, apparently, the extreme number of kids suspended or expelled, with significant racial disparity, when Binienda was superintendent. Under public pressure, Binienda reduced the number of suspensions.
That Member Kathy Roy voted with them is a near constant. The three operate in lockstep.
Member Alex Guardiola and Mayor Joe Petty made comments about Mailman’s resolution that appeared to be supportive of it, before McCullough introduce her amended version. However, both focused their comments on “everybody.”
They both voted against Mailman’s version, and for McCullough’s, when the votes were tallied.
Petty’s vote appears to contradict his statement supporting the citizen petition before the city council on Tuesday, February 11. That petition has attracted more public attention, largely based on public hysteria about the term “sanctuary city.”
It doesn’t bode well for the petition at city council. While it appeared last week that the resolution has enough support to pass, expect some bait and switch. Maybe an unannounced, clearly orchestrated, full re-write of the resolution to include a bunch of people the federal government didn’t just declare canceled.
Trans Science in an Election Year
This isn’t about inclusivity. It is about an election year, and pandering to trans bigots who love to claim that being trans is “playing dress up.” Many of those same people launch into tirades of conspiracy theories about scientists being “woke,” when you point out the science being developed as early as 2012.
By 2012, studies were showing monozygotic (identical) twins having a much higher rate of both being transgender than dizygotic twins. Monozygotic twins occur when a single sperm fertilizes a single egg that splits into two after fertilization.
The genetic makeup of monozygotic twins is almost identical, with nearly 100 percent similarities. The prevalence of both identical twins being transgender, and the rarity of the occurrence in monozygotic twins, shows a likely genetic component to gender non-conformity, though identification of genetic markers has not occurred.
While science hasn’t yet reached a consensus on the origin of gender dysphoria, it has concluded it is not pathological (caused by a physical or mental disease). The American Psychiatric Association stopped using the label of “gender identity disorder” in 2013, and the World Health Organization did so in 2019.
Imagine instead of being aimed at trans people, the president’s executive order targeted Irish people. How fast and how hard would the six members that voted against this resolution be tripping over each other to their voice support for Irish heritage? Would it include a long list of other ethnicities in the name of inclusivity?
Of course not. Some groups are entitled to exclusivity.
An example of that exclusivity played out inside the city council in October 2023. Some city councilors couldn’t wait to pass a resolution condemning the attacks on October 7, 2023, in Israel, and rejected any amendments to include any reference to the higher number of Palestinian casualties that had already occurred by the time they voted.
In a later interview with Talk of the Commonwealth with Hank Stolz, (starting at 10:20) Councilor Bergman, who brought the resolution condemning the attacks, suggested it was taking part in antisemitic hate to vote against his resolution, despite his rejection of amendments.
If that was antisemitism then, then this must be transphobia? If that was anti-Semitism, weren’t the cowardly objections to the ceasefire resolution, which did make specific mention of Israeli hostages, Islamophobia and/or taking part in anti-Arab hate?
Don’t be silly. Logic has no place in campaign season.














